» Tue Nov 16, 2010 4:42 pm
Well, in Tamriel, there doesn't seem to be much research going on in what we would call science in real life, likely because of the fact that the world itself doesn't have the same workings as real life. But considering the nature of the Elder Scrolls world, I might argue that someone who studies magic or alchemy or weird metaphysical things, in the context of the setting, is really not all that different from someone who studies biology or physics in real life, and there are certainly people who do research on such subjects. The knowledge available to people in Tamriel of their own world has to come from somewhere, after all. And I'm sure that some of the people in say, the Mages Guild who research various subjects regard their research in a similar way to how a scientist in real life might regard his work.
If what scientists do is perform research in order to better understand how various things in the world work, then in the context of a setting where magic is as much a part of the universe as weather, is someone who studies magic really any less of a scientist than someone who studies chemistry or astronomy would be in real life? Obviously, to us, magic is not science, but that's because magic is a fictional element that is removed from real world science. But if we consider, for the sake of argument, that there was, in fact, a world where magic was very much real and plays a role in shaping said world, and was researched by people, often through hypothesis and experimentation, much like real scientists, would the people who research it not look at it as another form of science? Now, the narrative probably wouldn't call it science, because calling someone who uses powers that are clearly magic would probably seem weird to most audiences, but technically speaking, I don't think there's really much of a difference in the Elder Scrolls world.