Oh... yeah... hahahaha... I didn't do that... I swear....XD well, I failed the speech check, I was angry!! XD
I always save, throw em off, then reload and convince him to live.
If you tell him to just jump himself, he runs but lands in the water. Yet dies.
You don't die from landing in water you idiot! :swear:
In real life you might, if you're that old and frail, but in-game, if you land in water, you survive no matter what.
I guess he's just meant to die. :shrug: