I do not wish to sound offensive but I have made several comments on why Boone is
not OP and what the consequences of saying Boone is OP are, without solid proof. He is basically a very-well put together companion. Please read http://www.gamesas.com/index.php?/topic/1129556-boone/page__p__16560093__fromsearch__1entry16560093:
This is a breakdown of a companion anolysis because I think too many people are complaining of companion OP without understanding the mechanics behind it, Boone notably leading to the programmers nerfing the wrong thing. First of all:
Companion nerve boosts the level of your companions Armor and Damage, it is set by your S.P.E.C.I.A.L Charisma as such:
Charisma:
1: A/D +5%
2: A/D + 10%
3: A/D + 15%
4: A/D + 20%
5: A/D + 25%
6: A/D + 30%
7: A/D + 35%
8: A/D + 40%
9: A/D + 45%
10: A/D + 50%
Now I am only going to use Boone here because he is notably the most affected, and most players experience him as their first companion. His stats can be found in wiki under "Craig Boone".
I've made an accurate reasoning that he is in fact not OP:
Let's say the average player has a Charisma of 5 therefore his/her nerve is 5 also meaning +25% Damage/Armor to companions.
Taking this http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Craig_Boone which you may criticize, Boone has a Gun rating of 54.
His scoped rifle has a Dam rating of 45.
25% of 45 = +11.25 DAM(per shot)
Therefore in total his Dam, per shot, will be 56.25 Dam per shot.
Combined with a sneak of 54 and using a rifle he will most likely Hidden Critical his first shot every time.
He wears a 1st Recon Beret, granting +1 PER; +5 Crit which will be frequent given his Shot ratio of 0.78 per second.
Nerve 10.
50% of 45 = +22.50 DAM(per shot)
Therefore in total his Dam, per shot, will be 67.5 Dam per shot.
Think about that, there is barely anything in the game that has a DT or resistance level remotely near that unless your in the highly dangerous areas. That is why he is killing entire legions and platoons, they have a measley DT of at most, 7-10. So that leaves 46Damage ( Nerve 5) or 57 Damage ( Nerve 10) unchecked. Still think Boone is OP?
The reason I am adamant in pointing this out is that if too many people complain about Boone without understanding the mechanics behind him or any of the companions. Everyone says he is too OP because he is the first one you meet/obtain and frankly the most powerful as pointed out. Slowly am I seeing more complaints of companion OP. I do not wish to see him nerfed blindly because of misinterpreted complaints.
If you were to complain you'd have to look at all the other companions, I will do this if the community wishes to see the data on them too but at a later time. If I were to point out what is OP, I'd say the combination of the above not the individual statistics.
Reno
If Boone, and all companions get nerfed because of this - and there is no grey area he will be in your words OP or under-Powered - I will be saddened. If he is OP, it is because of the combination of all his assets: Gun SP/Weapon/Apparel/Charisma Nerve and not Boone is simple OP.
Reno