I really don't have much to say that others already haven't.
You seem to be doing pretty well for yourself here. You're progressing the plot nicely, and it's difficult to guess what will happen next, which does wonders for the suspense. I would have preferred to know a bit more about the circumstances and characters earlier, having no experience with the RP... but that was a deliberate choice on your part, so I'll let it be.
You're still moving very quickly. Slow down your pace by using sensory descriptions. Use a lot of description especially in the important parts: descriptions help us linger in the moment, and that's what pulls us into the story.
What Bmont is referring to is the fact that not every line needs the dialogue tag ("Desmond said," "Gold-Heart replied," "Ocato told him," etc) if it's obvious who's talking. This is something you should be building a sense of, if you read a lot (you
do pick up a book every once in a while, right? :stare: )
It's awesome to see you still writing, and I'm once again surprised by how openly you welcome criticism. It's refreshing. You're also obviously doing your best to put the advice into action. I can see where you put in vivid descriptions and tried to smooth out your dialogue. Make no mistake; there is improvement. Keep practicing, and soon we'll all have nothing to complain about. :celebration:
There is one thing that others have said, however, that bears repeating (and apparently beating, like the proverbial dead horse).
From what I've seen of you, your weakness is by far your dialogue. This is something that will require some sort of paradigm shift to get a grasp on, and I'm not sure how to help you wrap your head around what, exactly, is wrong with it. Take this excerpt, for example.
Desmond reluctantly said, "The Sentinels, they killed them, the ones we killed the Ice King with, they lie dead, engraved on the chest of each of them is a sword with a dragon above it, and below the sword it has runes of an unknwon language, most likely the language of the sentinels." He then added, "I know this, because I found their corpses and buried them myself, before we decided to stay together."
(I'm not going to comment on the comma over-use, because others already have.
)
Do you see how stiff and over-dramatic this dialogue is? Think of a cheesy 60s sci-fi movie or something. If characters deliver lines like this with flat faces... they tend to evoke laughs.
The fact that Desmond feels the need to reiterate that their friends are dead is repetative and heavy-handed. Name dropping the Ice King is unnatural, since that isn't how a sentence of this kind would be structured. Then, he continues to give information that you obviously want us to know, yet seems to come out of left field. Perhaps if Gold-Heart had asked more about the circumstances, it would be believable. But it's simply not realistic in that particular clump.
On that note, the gigantic paragraph of "While you were out..." given by the Dunmer girl is another obvious attempt to give us information through dialogue. While it's better to have it through dialogue than a thick paragraph in the narration, this is still an obvious information dump. You, the author, were obviously talking through her, and that is something that should
never be obvious.
Here's something that D.Foxy pointed out to me not long ago: every piece of dialogue should do two things: advance the story and tell us about the character. Your dialogue advances the story just fine... but there's simply no personality behind it. It's dramatic--and that's good--but it's also generic.
I'm not sure how to help you see this. You're trying--I can tell you are--but you still lack that little spark of characterization.
I'm going to once again suggest that you read a couple books... but this time, steer clear of anything epic (like fantasy or science fiction). Dig up a book of literary fiction... something based on characters and not plot. Pay attention to how dialogue works; how it sounds different coming from different people. Everyone has a different voice: different wants, different education, different likes and dislikes, even different slang.
What's more, pay attention to what real people sound like, rather than what characters in an epic fantasy novel sound like. Real people aren't going to clutch one another close and declare their undying love and devotion, much less over and over again as Desmond and Gold-Heart did. Real people aren't going to tell an abridged history of the Provinces without either being interrupted, showing some emotion, or giving some sort of opinion.
The key thing to keep in mind is subtlety. Dialogue is an excellent tool for revealing characters and settings, but only when used with a light touch. If you handle it too heavily, you could accidentally strangle it.
Again, this is something that will take practice. Keep reading and writing (both are equally important!), and you'll naturally get a sense for these things.
Urk. I think I was a bit heavy-handed there, myself. :facepalm: