» Sun May 08, 2011 12:51 pm
While I'm a huge fan of The Elder Scrolls I also love other big RPG series. I'm also a huge Final Fantasy fan and I respect Blizzard for WoW's success even though I don't play that game.
One thing to consider is that The Elder Scrolls games (thus far at least) do not radically change from game to game. This is also only the fifth in the series. To an outside observer it might not appear Final Fantasy has changed just due to the name having such a high number now, but the fact is Final Fantasy radically reinvents itself if not every few games sometimes every game.
Final Fantasy I - A basic story and hard menu-based game play.
Final Fantasy II - Completely scraps levels for a leveling system similar to TES, but very unbalanced (attack yourself to gain health, etc).
Final Fantasy III - Job system
Final Fantasy IV - For the first time a large emphasis is put on telling a story. ATB introduced and becomes very common in the series.
Final Fantasy V - More lighthearted story, again uses a Job system.
Final Fantasy VI - My favorite story in the series, again uses a different character advancement system.
Final Fantasy VII - Reduces party to three and adds many mini-games, again using a new character ability system.
Final Fantasy VIII - Once again uses another character ability system. Of note this game uses leveled enemies.
Final Fantasy IX - A throwback to the first six with many easter eggs. You absorb abilities from equipment.
Final Fantasy X - The first game to not use ATB since FFIV. The game's focus as a pilgrimage gives it a very different feel story wise.
Final Fantasy XI - An MMORPG... personally I try to not link that with them.
Final Fantasy XII - A far more open world than usual in the series. You customize your party with what amounts to limited programming, though you can still intervene. For the first time in the single player games, enemies are not triggered in random battles.
Final Fantasy XIII - A radical shift back to ATB with a completely unique battle system. Describing it would take too long here.
Final Fantasy XIV - A failed MMORPG.
That turned out to be way too long, but my point is Final Fantasy is not the same rehashed game over and over. Each game has different characters and worlds and stories. Most of the time you could give the games their own names and they'd still work. There are just some common elements in the series that make them stand out, but the games stand on their own. A FF game could fall flat on its face and the next could be a smashing success. They are that different sometimes.
If The Elder Scrolls lasts that long it will need to evolve more than it does now. It won't become like a radically different genre of course, but the games by necessity need to be far apart in release as they are now or they run the risk of being carbon copy clones that people will get bored of. Us devout fans would eat them up of course, but they need to apply to more than their core fanbase over time.
MMORPGs are different and it's one of the reasons I do not want an Elder Scrolls MMORPG. MMORPGs are mostly about interaction with other players. I play an MMORPG now that I've been playing for nearly eight years now. While I do enjoy the game sometimes it's more like a job... but one that I enjoy because I like playing with my friends. Timesinks and friends come way before fun to a long time MMORPG player much of the time. Perhaps WoW does it better than the one I play right now, but I have a feeling it's much the same for that one. I'll give the topic creator credit for only listing WoW 3 though. MMORPGs can survive a long time. There are several active MMORPGs that still receive new expansions that are going on 12+ years old now.
To get back to the original question, I don't think they could do that feasibly unless it was an MMORPG. They would have to either release the game in episodes which add to the continent each game or the game would be either smaller per province or mostly randomly generated.
In short: I don't think we're going to see all of Tamriel at once again unless it's randomly generated or an MMORPG.