They're not all crazy for Skyrim. I was listening to the latest episode of Invisible Walls on Gametrailers, and TESV was but a speck to them compared to Uncharted 3 and Arkham City. They said the trailer and its unveiling was laughable and moved on to other games. Sure, there are peeps like Andrew Reiner that have the opposite reaction, but they're getting different info too.
That's good. Because you know, I can't take anyone seriously who claims ME2's dialogue system is deep and well made and that Shepard is an interesting character. Just something I read amongst plenty others. Or how Splinter Cell conviction is a killer SC sequel... It seems to me that most only care about cheap, "exciting" game mechanics and things that makes a game less deep, not that every game has to be complex and not just a fun game, but each time I read a review they're totally on the opposite of what I look forward to.