While I was sneaking around Skyrim, I came upon an Orc camp. The Orc said I needed to find The Forgemaster's Fingers in order to enter the camp. I did, and now when I walk up to them, there is no option to hand them in. It just has the same dialog options about gaining access to the camp.
Is there a console command to rest the quest? Nothing in my journal shows up about the The Forgemaster's Fingers quest.

Try "setstage FavorOrcsIntro 20"

I know you can't use it to go back quest stages but setting it to the stage where you are supposed to turn it in might work. If we had the CK we could look up their faction.

Otherwise, try doing "player.addfac CrimeFactionOrcs " with different numbers, probably a multiple of 5 or 10.

The UESPwiki has the stage number for (probably) every quest in the game.

Here's their specific page on the Forgemaster's Fingers: http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Skyrim:The_Forgemaster%27s_Fingers

EDIT: Ninja'd, lol.

Thanks guys, I tried the setstage etc and it worked like a charm Thank you