It's fine for the style that Skyrim is going for. Rugged, yet with a shine to it. I think the fact people are fine with how the menus look and not how the map looks is just a placement of how much one wants all pretty things to be practical. I like hand drawn maps, but I am completely cool with Skyrim using this method.
disagree 100% I dislike both the new map and the menus. I dont want to see some fancy high tech ipod scrolling display while looking at my items, and i think the functionality of it on the pc is going to be terrible. I will absolutely hate it if i have to scroll through everything ipod style. Playing on pc id rather have all info available and infront of me at once.
And i dont see where you are getting that a 3D Google maps gps map fits into the rugged nord culture of skyrim.
It looks nice, I just think it's so wrong for this kind of game.
Not only does a parchment map suit the fantasy setting better, but I think the simpler design aids the sense of discovery in an open-world game. I really enjoy finding things out for myself and feeling lost at times - for me that's half the fun of an open-world game. The 3D map almost looks like it's too good at what it does.
agree with this completely.