She confronts you no matter what, if you start asking around about the holotapes. However, as others have stated, her strong suggestion about how to resolve the quest is just an option and by no means a requirement.
Thank you.
I really like his plasma rifle, so I plan on getting it whether I am good or evil!
One last thing. If she were to accidentally get killed, would that pooch the quest at all or have any dire effects in the future?