Im not sure on the gun but Im still on quest one, broc flower etc. I always go for the greatest per centage on the body. I watch the blood spurt from a perfect head shot but still end up dead. I guess I need to get used to game and how it all works as Ive only really played RDR and Mafia 2 before this.
Well even a head shot will seldom kill a target unless you are 'hidden' from him, or get a crit.
A good trick is to use vats till you run out of points... at that point you are kinda aiming at where you want to shoot anyway. Just go ahead and unload your clip into the man till he is dead.