hmm....
only "ONE OF US"?
So we can rule out any of the theories that several people subscribed to, right?
this means
- no Argonian
- no goblin
are there any theories out there proposed by only one of us?
- scamp?
- Dragon Priest?
Just to throw a spanner into the works:
It's true to say that one person accurately described the picture even if more than one accurately described the picture. It's like if I eat three apples and say "I ate one apple". It's true. But it is misleading, because there is a conversational norm of Be Maximally Informative! We don't interpret "I ate N apples" as being "I ate at least N apples", because that's not very informative (for what value of M did I eat N + M apples?).
So that's just a long-winded way of saying: if Vsions is being a little tricky and deliberately flouting conversational norms (for the purposes of teasing us
) then we can't rule out hypotheses mentioned by more than one poster.