Sadly I think most skyscraqers would be fallen and make the city a large pile of rubble...
In a real-world scenario, assuming the nukes didn't just scoure the city clean, all the way to the bedrock? You're right.
But, look at some alternate ideas. What if, instead of destroying all the skyscraqers entirely, the nukes just blew off the TOPS of MOST of them (with a few mostly-intact ones around) ...? What if New York's anti-nuclear shell was strong enough, few nukes actually hit INSIDE the city - instead landing AROUND it. And, what if those "around it" nukes triggered the
very real and very dangerous fault-line beneath the city ... and
sank the city fifty or so feet, straight down ...? Let's also posit that some of the metro system retained it's integrity - and had the exits directly to the streets sufficiently clogged with debris from the blasted-off TOPS of the skyscraqers. Thus, despite being plunged so far down - and despite the rubble being thoroughly flooded - SOME parts of the metro system are dry (at least partially) and not collapsed (at least,
partially). And finally, while teh island sinks, the floor of the harbor RISES - so Staten Island isn't an island anymore, it's a hill in the middle of a saltwater marsh.
So ... picture a ruined New York where the broken, perhaps leaning-at-crazy-angles remnants of skyscraqers jut up from a foetid morass of radioactive swamp and sludge. Natural and artificial causeways link some buildings; rope- and cable-suspended bridges like others; and a few can only be reached via the ruined Metro system. A much more VERTICAL environment than prior Fallouts have been, certainly. Maybe a ship or two gets driven into the heart of Manhattan Island ... or rather, the
bog that USED to be Manhattan!
I think that could be an AWESOME experience, to explore an urban ruin of that amazing scale and scope - and
claustrophobia. Instead of wide-open spaces everywhere, you've got
interiors everywhere. And even the outside - either you're on a bridge, or at a window, and can't GET to anything you see "Way over there" (not directly, anyway) ... or you're down in the muck and yuck of the bogs, and can't see very far due to the constant fog.
Skip the Supermutants entirely (well, maybe a token couple - Fawkes might make it up to NYC several years post-Broken Steel, for example). Instead, your "brutish barbarians" can come in the form of ...
mutated intelligent RATS. After all, what's more iconically New York than
giant rats ...? Except these're smart enough to use melee weapons, and even some GUNS.
And they breed like rabbits. Sure, none of them are as imposing, individually, as a supermutant. But where you might have found two or three supermutants ... you instead find TEN "Rat-kin".
Radroaches would still be in, of course. And radscorpions. And deathclaws - a local SCALED variety, reminiscent of .... ALLIGATORS. ^_^ Because after rats, "sewer-croc" is also pretty darned iconic for a major urban environment like NYC.
...
And in my mind, I have this image of a wet, mold- and lichen-overrun, fog-choked swamp/bog. Out of the mists rise the broken and crumbling remains of former skyscraqers; bridges, some in dubious states of repair, link a few of the ruined buildings here and there; one or two show areas of lights, and probable habitation. And finally, in the center of a large stretch of open bog rises a hill ... on which the decapitated and partly-skeletal remains of the Statue of Liberty can
just be made out through the fog.
...
Good lord, I would
SO rush out and
immediately buy that, if it were available right now! :tops:
NOTE to Bethesda: if you think this idea is HALF as awesome as I think it is, PLEASE make it. I hereby officially surrender all rights, interests, and other elements of control or ownership in this idea, real or imagined, to Bethesda Game Studios in perpetuity - no compensation or consideration need ever be offered or tendered to me, neither by you nor any third party to whom you might delegate the development rights for a game with such a setting. IOW: "the idea belongs to you, now".
Of course, if you're feeling REALLY and ESPECIALLY grateful and generous ... a comp copy, guaranteed beta spot, and maybe a byline in the credits (which'd give me "ultimate bragging rights" forever) ...? Would make me an extremely happy really devoted fan!!