Total War is definitely one of my favorite game series, ever since Shogun, despite a few obvious quirks - I find that the mark of a really great game is how many shortcomings you're willing to overlook because you're just enjoying it so much. It's one of the few games where I find myself coming up with stories of conquest and adventure to complement the gameplay, and each playthrough ends up unique. I still lament bitterly about the cruel injustice done to the great Prince Friedrich of the Holy Roman Empire (in Medieval 1) - a natural-born leader, military genius, and political savant who, while leading a glorious force several thousand strong, was struck on horseback by a single trebuchet missile, the very
first shot, as he marched at the head of his army. No one else was hit but him, struck down before he could ascend the throne as the greatest emperor of all time. Alas, poor Friedrich!
I could have easily reloaded a savegame, but it's one of those games where even defeat adds another layer to the narrative, and I generally accept the outcome whatever the cost.
Medieval 1 is still my favorite of the series - it had the best overall presentation and the best character traits. I liked the new campaign map introduced in Rome, which added a whole new layer of maneuver on a grand scale, but some of the visuals started becoming a little generic and a lot of the aesthetic that made Medieval so rich was lost. Same with Medieval 2: it was a great game, but lacked the same charm that Medieval 1 had, and it took several mods to improve it. However, Medieval 2 is still one of my most-played games of all time (right up there with Civ IV.) Empire was mostly a disappointment, incredibly resource-heavy and without much difference between the nations or their units, but the addition of naval warfare was awesome (though not to everyone's taste, I imagine.) Haven't been too keen on getting Napoleon since it seems to limit the campaign map so much, and it's largely the same game as Empire, which just didn't appeal to me as much as previous Total Wars. Looking forward to seeing how Shogun 2 turns out, though - looks very exciting so far!
... anyone with Medieval 2 needs to check out the Third Age mod. It is Lord of the Rings themed but very fun.
I absolutely love the Third Age mod for Medieval 2: Kingdoms. It's one of my favorite ever mods, and captures the spirit and depth of Tolkien's world better than any other Lord of the Rings game. The War of the Ring is so perfectly suited to the Total War style of gameplay, and with the clever way they adapted the holy crusade aspect to fit Middle Earth, I think it's even one of the best versions of Total War. Any Tolkien fan who likes Total War should definitely give it a go.