Gheez, I know 16 isn't exactly a fully-developed human being (I'd know being 17, though really I've been forced to mature to 18), but it's old enough to have developed understanding and knowledge of these sorts of things. I know people who were playing R18 games aged 7 who haven't turned into psychopathic killers yet.
I don't know how American ratings would work, but dammit I know I'd rebel - I've seldom gone against my parents my entire life, I never usually have a reason to, so when I have they knew that [censored] just got real. Buy an R16 movie. When parent has a hissy fit, lay down the law... literally, you're legally enabled to purchase and own that product by the government, they've obviously agreed that 16 is an appropriate age to have developed enough knowledge of the world to deal with the content. Accuse parent of opposing the government and call them a commie. Win.
:ph34r:
The laws must be different over there because in the states it is just a rating system that limits the SELLER as to who they can and cannot sell the product to. Has nothing to do with consumption. A warped parent who wants to scar a child can let a 5 yr old watch a M rated horror flick legally in their own home.
So your little "legal" argument wouldn't hold water over here. Also, a good parent will work with the kid. My boy is 6 and we started reading War of the Worlds but he got scared by it. I was surprised since he loves sci-fi and has no problems with aliens and humans fighting etc etc. The difference we hadn't read/watched anything where Earth got attacked and the humans massacred. So now off to Journey to the Center of the Earth.
And some of you guys are a bit over the top when it comes to arguing about the blood vs violence. Yes it does appear a bit silly on the surface but as the OP's dad implied there is a difference between cartoon violence and realistic violence. I think 16 is plenty old that the parent should know if the kid can handle it or not, but that's his call and not mine. Also, I think the OP should've gotten some credit for being honest instead of trying to lie or hide it like some of you hoodlums here
Technically, if a game is R16, but you're under 18 and living with a legal guardian (usually parents), then they still have a legal right to say "No, you're not allowed that" - EVEN when you bought it with your own money.
They legally have to return it when you're 18 though, or you can charge them with theft.
Yea calling the cops on your parents is a great way to resolve issues like a $50 video game. And there is no chance they won't use the law to throw you out, or say unplug your computer from MY electrical outlet right?