Do any of these games svck/have hideous bugs? I know the basic premise of the game, and I think I know the genre/gameplay style, but I don't know if the game is actually any good. I like games that have a strong story/character development, and I tend to stay away from games that are mindless combat/hack-and-slash (even if they are addictive hack-and-slash).
Stonekeep
Stonekeep is an...interesting game. There is a lot of fighting, some puzzles; one of the flaws that I saw was that at the beginning it can be really difficult to kill things without throwing an arrow repeatedly at a creature. (Yes, throwing it). Later on there is a certain speed spell which can about break the game because it's as if your bow has been turned into a machine-gun. The only downside is picking all those arrows back up.
The graphics aren't bad, but the voice acting can be. It's not the worst I've heard, though, by any means.
Some people like it, some people hate it.
This game is difficult for a beginner to just jump into; if you decide to play it, I recommend looking up some helpful strategies on character development(there are still some active forums for this game out there). Also, some quests shouldn't precede others...iirc...it has something to do with the guilds. In the time I played it, it was quite entertaining, although I wasn't efficiently building my characters(it began to show after a while). I liked how the system worked to talk to NPCs. The environments were interesting as well.
There are a few bugs in the game, but I didn't notice them so bad while playing. Just try to get the latest patch and everything should be alright.
The only bug I did run into had to do with pooling gold in the tavern. It might have been fixed by now, but it's easy enough to avoid.
Very entertaining game, I really liked it, except that I only got to play it for about 2 hours. A game-breaking bug caused the dwarf not to show up and so I couldn't continue. This was with the latest patch.
One of my favorite games. Probably in the top 3.
Most likely difficult for a beginner, so you should look for helpful tips or ask for advice (I would be willing to answer any questions).
There's two joinable opposing factions, a huge tree city (Trynton), an interesting storyline, and...a lot of fights! The fighting is tactical and turn-based, and you *can avoid* fights unlike in previous Wizardry games. The chameleon spell will make it harder for enemies to notice you. Being in search-for-items mode makes it easier for them to notice you.
You can set up how your party is positioned. Obvious: place the mages in the back rows and fighters in the front, with bards and such in the middle. To cover up the back row of the party, you actually *should* back yourself into a corner so the enemies cannot reach those characters (unless your front lines are killed).
The music is nice, and the environments...well, they're efficient enough. Definitely not as pretty as today's game, but don't need to be. There's humor and darkness. A few easter egg NPC comments (since you can type in words to say). Also, some easter egg retro-dungeons!
Skills go up as you use them, so bards should use any and all excuses to use their music, gadgeteers their gadgets, and etc.
The voice acting is excellent! Especially one of the chaotic male voices who got some really good lines - "Paralyzed...what am I supposed to do? BLINK people to death?!"
The only problem with it is that it's hard to get the game CDs. They're rare, and cost what a new just-released game today ($50-90) would cost.