I agree with Robbio on most points. I approve of all of the mods except TeeHee. The timezone thing doesn't apply for her because she's in roughly the same time zone as Undone and Wampbit. And it's impossible to say "yeah, and her online hours match up conveniently too" for her because she hasn't been on for nearly the whole existence of this world. My main problem is that she has broken rules in the past. She was warned by Wampit when she let DemonicPopcorn in because mean old Antibody said we should stop giving such new members the IP. In fact her breaking this rule of only mods handing out IPs directly resulted in Wampbit making the rules we have today. If she had no respect for the rules in the past, I find it hard to believe she will now, and even if she does, I still find it laughable that she was promoted to mod while CaffinatedJedi was demoted for being just as inactive as her. It just seems like a clear case of favoritism and nothing more.
TeeHee had been given my permission to give the IP after we'd discussed whether or not we should let him in in-game with the rest who were on. Wampbit wasn't online at the time. Afterwards, Wamp and I discussed what the entry criteria should be, which led to the updated rules. Wamp's "warning" for TeeHee came because, at that point, he didn't know I'd given her permission.
And so you thought making someone who was "disinterested" in the map a mod was a good idea? If Teehee isnt interested in the server, then why on earth would you make her a moderator? I havent seen Teehee on the new map whatsoever. Its all well and good to say that she's talked about it on Steam, but that doesnt qualify as proper activity. If we had a new moderator on these very forums who'd been gone for a long time saying they weren't interested, only to come back with a position of power, we'd hardly call that fair would we?
:shrug: I've been disinterested. The separatist set-up doesn't really do it for me. She's been communally active in the past, was active in discussions as to how the server can be improved, and made it clear she would be active if a new community project was introduced. And as I said, there was a personal issue that took her away from Minecraft, BGSF, Steam et al for a while.
I'm glad to see that he's been reinstated, but you understand, suddenly promoting a bunch of unelected mods for a community server while suddenly demoting a couple of old ones without notice is hardly appropriate is it? Anyway, not being active hasnt stopped other individuals becoming mods has it?
As I said, all the new mods are either currently active, or have been actively involved in discussions about how to make the server more interactive, and have indicated that they will be highly active if a more interactive set-up is introduced. We need mods who are keen to drive forward the new game plans. If people have been inactive (in the case of Pete, he was only really highly active in pre-Aldgate days) for a while, I think it makes sense to remove them from the list so people can easier see who to contact etc.
I'd like to report Blahberry.
...
Duly noted.