Hi
Pretty much, veronica becomes by companion and then will say something about how i said the brotherhood were bad and then she'll become hostile. I know to get her to join you have to speak positively about the brotherhood which I do, i chose the "they've got the right idea" speech option. Is it 'cos i have bad rep with the brotherhood?
Cheers

Bad rep?
Are you vilified?
Cause if you have bad rep then it's possible she won't join you.

Wikia entry:

"If you talk negatively about the Brotherhood in your first conversation, she won't join you."

"Veronica's staying with the player is tied with his or her Brotherhood reputation. If it drops to Wild Child or below, Veronica will state that the player seems determined to fight the Brotherhood, and will leave the player."

"you have destroyed the Brotherhood Bunker in Hidden Valley before recruiting her, she will come up to you and ask you what you know about the Brotherhood at 188. If you tell her what you did, she will say "Well in that case: This is for them." and become hostile, attacking the player."

Ahaha, yeah im villified, that'll probably be it
I was trying to get "The Whole Gang's Here" Achievment, but meh :rolleyes:

I'm not going to ask why you would have a bad rep with the Brotherhood but that is most certainly the problem.

Just a tip to get that achievment, you're gonna have to use a good character. As in one that's somewhat of a saint seeing as certain companions won't join you if your rep is below a certain point with a certain faction except the Legion. They all hate the legion.... <_<

Case doesn't really care, nor does Rex, or ede, or lily. What do you mean they all hate legion...have you played he game?

He may have been referring to the factions, not individual companions. The Khans before you expose the Legion are the only faction who is kinda ok with them.

With the way he worded it he meant companions. Legion playthrough is my third fav. The only reason is because I don't like an ego-tistical [censored] (mr house) leading I, Robot. Legion fanatics are just ticked that they don't get an ex-centurion companion. But that'd be a duplicate Boone. Boone is the best companion anyways

I want Dead Sea as a companion, he's a Decanus and not an ex-legionnaire. :mellow:

Well, I dno whats happened, but i just recruited raul, and i got the whole gangs here achievment? Ah Well :spotted owl: :fallout: :celebration:

On a side note, I'm also going for that achievement and I have a question.


*SPOILERS*











I recruited Cass but sent her to her death by giving her up to the Van Graffs. I figured this wouldn't effect the achievement because it just says recruit every companion but nothing about keeping them all. Anyone know for sure?

If you have recruited them even once you're GTG. I rectuited Arcade last and as soon as he agreed to go with me I got the trophy. (PS3)