http://i.imgur.com/WehmJoe.jpg
Anyone who has an idea what might be causing. My first guess was Vertical Syncing (although it doesn't look like the tearing you usually get sometimes w/o it), but it's the same with or w/o VS. Can it be that I'm running both HDR (via the game) and AA (via CCC)? Weird.
EDIT: Yes, that might be it. Switching from HDR to Bloom, removed it. But I'd like to have both HDR and AA...