That is why they have so many categories. Then they choose which one is the most astoundingly greatest in that category and make it the game of the year, or something like that.
Black ops should not be up there IMO. I love it and played it to bits but DAMN did it get boring fast. The story is great, reminiscent of Shutter Island, and the online is terrific. The game is just not an improvement enough to be GOTY.