Round 1 Results.
Street Fighter VS The Elder Scrolls WIN! :celebration:
Civilization VS Fallout WIN! :celebration:

Round 2. StarCraft VS The Elder Scrolls :toughninja:
http://www.g4tv.com/deathmatch/best-franchises-2011/battle/86/starcraft-vs-the-elder-scrolls/

Another nominee, Fallout VS Gears of War :disguise:
http://www.g4tv.com/deathmatch/best-franchises-2011/battle/81/fallout-vs-gears-of-war/

ATM, Elder Scrolls is winning with 51%! :celebration:
But we have 4 days left...

Yay! Lets make those 4 days a success! :foodndrink:

LOL. Good choice for competitors.

I say SF, just because you could be anywhere in the world and run into SF cabs. + its simple and very complicated at the same time. Also, they have Chun Li.

Does Marvel vs Capcom fall under the SF franchise?

Those are some pretty ridiculous comparisons. TES all the way.

So its just like march mayhem only games instead of devs... Meh will pass, some overrated game will win.

Is Grand Theft Auto in there? If I could be bothered to vote, that's what I'd vote for.

Yeah GTA is up against Half-Life (GTA is winning 54-46)

I believe it falls into the Capcom vs What-have-you franchise

The comments are rage worthy on that STvsES page

What a crappy comparison.

Here's an idea, why not compare two franchises that have something even remotely in common.

Was never into fighting games other than Super Smash.As for the other match up I have only played 2 Civilizations and they where pretty good.

TES and FO get my votes.

Indeed, i stopped reading them when i realized my IQ started dropping.

With Civilization vs. Fallout, I have to go with Civ. Sorry guys

I could care less, if it had Fallout 1 vs. Deus Ex or Deux Ex Human Revoluton vs. Mass Effect 3, I'de go for DX.

It's alright, at least you voted for Oblivion.

I mean... you voted for Oblivion... right!?!?!

Street Fighter vs STarcraft. Now that is a very epic match up. Can't make a decision, would have to flip a coin on it.

UPDATED: Round 2! :toughninja:

I would go with Street Fighter because it has less micromanagement. Starcraft is not a strategy game, it is a micromanagement game. If you gave the units commands for destinations and level of aggressiveness (instead of giving specific commands to every unit about what attacks and abilities it will use) it might be an actual strategy game. As it stands now, Starcraft is based on whoever can perform the most actions per second.

Oh Em Gee!!1 The next battle might be TES vs WoW
:spotted owl:

Indeed. That's why I still hold that Age of Empires is the greatest RTS series ever made. It truly takes strategy and there is still micromanagement but it isn't the entire game, it's mostly just an advantage but it doesn't mean if you don't heavily micromanage you can't win, your attack plan decides if you win.



People keep thinking it should be a comparison of which is a better game in a genre. It's not about genre, it's about which one gave you more entertainment value and which franchise had more overall quality games. They aren't trying to compare them one which one was a better game gameplay to gameplay, they are comparing which game you liked most of the two. It's a random bracket like in a tournament, not set up by genre. That's like complaining that it's not fair to have Subzero vs. Nick Cage because they are too different.

Assassins Creed beats Battlefield??? Pwah! *Spits on ground* Assassins Creed is a repititive game that has a new sequel put out every year or two. Grrrrrrrr.........These results make me want to cry..........but I don't think this is meant to be taken seriously, I mean it's probably just for fun. After all, why'd they compare a RTS and an RPG, that'd be no way to do a real competition. Or has gaming journalism really fallen that far?

Wow, Starcraft vs Elder Scrolls has got to be one of the worst comparisons possible. They're about as similar as Heavy Rain is to Unreal Tournament...

I personally like Assassin's Creed more than I did any of the Battlefield games. I didn't see anything repetitive about AC, but that's me. But as I said above, it's not about comparing the two games on genre, it's about comparing which one of the two you liked playing the most, you can always compare that. They are random pair ups and you decide which one wins by voting for the one you liked playing the most. So if one game was more fun than the other to you, then it's a completely logical competition when comparing them, regardless of genre.