All this does is motivate people like me to not offer anything for free (and indeed, I no longer do public releases of original work for Oblivion). In any case, it's not true; almost as many people use my Poser freebies as my Oblivion ones, and not a single Poser/DAZ user has yet violated the terms of my readmes.
I don't think we disagree. I think people are generally good-natured. Its just that offering up things on the internet, for free, you can very easily lose control of whats yours. Myth is a good example. He wasn't aware of the restrictions you put on your creations. And when you corrected them, he took the mod down until further review.
The point is, he could have refused. We can't spend much time policing the internet, checking that mods are using our material property and giving credit, when we have no power whatsoever to make others obey rules set by us.
I'm primarily a writer, and I too would be upset if someone took credit, got a reward, etc for something I wrote. But that's the risk you take when putting something up onto the internet. If you are fearful of someone stealing your work, don't post it.
However, the internet is more than that. As we know, people still haven't stopped putting stuff on the net. In fact, free material--user made or otherwise--continues to grow. This, I believe, is a testament to the human race...something to throw at those
war-is-human-nature and
humans-are-basically-selfish people. The internet and its inhabitants really are a testament to the human capacity to share with each other.
All modders here, whether they were completely aware of it or otherwise, have sent their work in the metaphorical "basket-on-the-Nile" to whatever fate awaits it. Surely they don't expect money. They may certainly expect credit---but I would gamble to say that no one labors as hard as many modders here do simply because they want community praise from hundreds of faceless individuals. Modders mod because they want to create something they can enjoy. They release things onto the internet because they want others to enjoy them also.
The good feeling of community thanks and praise, then, outweighs the risk of bad feeling that would come as the result of being cheated. And I guess that people shouldn't even have to feel that way.
I'd hate to be a [censored] and quote myself, but I'm sure I heard this somewhere else before I repeated it in a similar situation that applied more to my life.
On a trip in DC, I had given this guy $20. He had said he and other guys had been collecting money to buy new basketball hoops for their court. A classmate of mine was aghast...and told me the guy probably cheated me. I mean, without any official information, just about ANYBODY could stand on the corner, think up a good cause, and ask people for money. My classmate was probably right. But I more or less said to him---and again I swear I heard this someplace else---
Whatever he does isn't on my conscious. I gave him money selflessly, because it felt good to do so. I might feel a little taken advantage of, but I don't regret it.
Sorry. Don't mean to hijack this thread. I promise to post no more.

Just thought I had to reply.