Same here. Well, until now. After reading these forums, I felt that it behooved me to create multiple for various quests.
Mass Effect 2 is the best game; you must try it if you have not. If you're into FPS games, then give BF3 a try. I, personally, love it; though, to be honest, I haven't played it ONCE since Skyrim has come out!
I so desperately want to play Batman: Arkham City.
You won't be disappointed. If you played Arkham Asylum, everything that game got right they did right this time around. The basic game mechanic is the same, but there's ton's of outdoor action, swinging around from building to building, and just tons more content. There's a leveling-up system that allows you to improve armor and gear and adds new combos, and the sheer size is awesome. New characters...the whole thing is just great. It's truly a near-flawless game.
OP: Try Skyrim again without the smithing-enchanting loop. That being said...Oblivion was a great game, but it Skyrim is light years beyond it. Going back to more primitive graphics in this sort of game will likely be difficult.