» Thu May 03, 2012 4:40 pm
Ahem. This is a warning from your friendly neighborhood lunar (looney?) spinnerette: crazy talk ahead.
The simplest answer to the question, "What is the Eye of Magnus?" is "The Eye of Magnus is the Eye of Magnus." Literally. Eyesore (ha, ha) has said that's the best way to understand these things, in a place like Tamriel; not that that particularly matters.
So it's his eye. His Eye. The Eye that beheld the plans of creation. And what is an eye, anyway? An Aperture (hardy har har), yes? A hole that admits light, when it comes down to it. But that's not what the Eye we saw in Skyrim does. No, the Eye we saw in Skyrim does the opposite: it emits light.
Now a tangent: the Staff of Magnus. Well, to draw some very overt and old-school connections: it's a [censored]. THE [censored]. Of Magnus. Don't ask me why he only has one testicle (edit: actually, I think SithisLorkhan explained this not too long ago). I won't go too much into the, 'Is the Staff of Chaos a Tower?' question, 'cause that's a whole additional can of worms, but I will say this: a Staff == a [censored] and a [censored] == the letter 'I' and the letter 'I' == a Tower; therefore, a Staff == a Tower. But here again, we have a slight malfunction - on the surface, at least. Cocks don't imbibe. They vomit. But the [censored] of Magnus only imbibes. Bit of a quandary.
So we have an Eye that shoots laser beams and a [censored] that drinks them; two inversions of 'normal' function. Now let's consider: the [censored] of Magnus is a Tower, Towers create a certain character of individual reality (in most cases, thereby reinforcing the Mundus' very existence), and Magnus jumped ship at the last moment deciding the project was a bad idea - so, integrating these three things, we can see that the [censored] acts as a Tower by imposing the desired reality of Magnus upon the Mundus, which is to say, unreality. It absorbs magicka because it is enforcing Magnus' attitude. You can call it Destruction of the Mundus, if you want to tie Magnus to Dagon.
And now the Eye, which does exactly the opposite thing from the Staff. And why? Well, I'm going for a combo: 1) inversion of function brought about by mythical trauma; the Singlefold Blinding. And 2) because of what Aranarkus said; it's a hole into Aetherius. There're some cultural references lying around (Mages Guild, I think?) that call the sun Magnus' Eye, right? So the Eye we saw in Skyrim is the sun, trapped in a Shell by who knows who - perhaps someone in a future Era, even - from whence Light, Magic pours forth.
So you've got a Staff that drinks magic and an Eye that vomits it (and the plans for existence branded on Its retina without any of the wisdom and temperance of Its Owner: thus the weirdo things), and bringing them together turns into a really twisted sixual deviancy (what the Archmage should have done to fix the problem was to throw the [censored] into the Eye and stop it up. And we could have had an Eclipse, which would have been fun).
Heh. I warned you. Craziness.