» Mon Mar 21, 2011 8:50 pm
Since this is obviously about enchanting rather than looks or other functions I have to vote:
Enchantment stacking makes the PC too powerful
Although, it's not really the "becoming too powerful" part that worries me, but how the then required balancing makes everything appear weak and uninspired, simply because it has to. Put limits on enchanting - like, if I'm a master enchanter I'm still not capable of making anything of legendary or artifact quality. It may help me in various ways, but never become uber because of it (or any other skill for that matter).
The rules of stacking should change too. Rather than being additive, the effect of the next item you add will be halfed. So you have three items at 20% resistance. Instead of it becoming 60%, it becomes 20% + 10% + 5%. Now, is it really worth spending that extra item to obtain that extra 5%, taking you from 30% to 35%? If you already have a racial bonus of 40% resistance, the first item is halved from its original value (to prevent overstacking). Each spell might also have a builtin max effect? Who knows...