OH COMON PEOPLE! Skyrim has already been done in sorts, remember Bloodmoon, Island that was like a mini Skyrim??!!! Not to mention Norse type mythology is a very overdone cliche of fantasy. Truthfully I don't really care where the game takes place but I'd rather it was J.R.R Tolkien elvish clone land that a desolate iceland. The one thing that makes me hate playing Fallout 3 is the landscape, and from everything I've heard Skyrim is the ugliest of them all!
Did Solstheim contain the intricate subversive qualities that are held by a province steeped in numerous kingdoms and city-states, all possibly conflicting with one another? Did it contain a plethora of royalty of all colors, to whom you could pledge allegiance and learn more about? Did it have thousand acre woods, rivulets and tributaries flowing through yawning chasms and canyons stretching all across the Hammerfell border? Does the traditional Norse Mythology you claim the Nordic culture imitates have some of the wisest wizards --Greybeards-- in Tamriel sequestered in its depths? Did it have a secluded school devoted entirely to the awestriking magical power of Thu'um, or the way of the Tongue? Did Solstheim have an astounding amount of magickal beasts, all hardened to survive in the intense climate, such as http://www.imperial-library.info/bestiaries/bloodmoon_large_giantfrost-1.jpg and possibly the feared http://www.imperial-library.info/tsomw/bm_udyrfrykte.jpgbeasts of legend?
No, Solstheim is definitely not Skyrim. Oh, and by the way, my vote is for Skyrim.