We all know Spears will win in votes but....
- What has been in previous Elder Scrolls games?
- What brings a different form of combat to the game?
- What hasn't been done yet, atleast not to the extent of modern games?
- What looks the coolest?
1. This is fulfilled by a lot of the weapons. Certainly Spears, Flails, Crossbows, and even Throwing Weapons have been in previous Elder scrolls games.
2. I think a Crossbow is basically the same as Bow and Arrow so I wouldn't say that's too different. Staffs are probably same as swords in terms of combat but they could bring a little bit different form of combat in terms of gameplay if they did it right. Flails are pretty much Maces but looks 10X's more badass. So I'de have to say Throwing Weapons or maybe the Whip bring the most different form of combat experience to the game.
3. We have seen spears, throwing weapons, and crossbows in plenty of modern day RPG's but we have not seen a Flail done well. It would be a challenge to get the physics of the ball at the end of the chain to work right when swinging it or when it's just hanging there but I think Bethesda are trailblazers and if anyone can do it first and more importantly do it right they can.
4. This is a tossup of opinion but for me it's a Flail. Nothing looks more brutal and intimidating then a flail for me. The massive force of this blunt or spikey ball smashing into shield or bone and flesh would sure cause a damaging impact. Even if they just included one of these weapons, as a sorta special find it would be awesome. Halberds are probably second on my list because they are just a multipurpose and deadly polearm variant that looks badass.
All in all I would have to say, and I voted for, Flails.
As others have said in the http://www.gamesas.com/index.php?/topic/1170767-new-weapon-flails/ thread... http://www.imperial-library.info/sites/default/files/gallery_files/dagger_shot04.jpg And people modded them into http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GOQ6PdxLCro and Oblivion. If Bethesda did them right they could be a very unique and menacing weapon, possibly special finds like how they treated some weapons in Morrowind.
Plus they just look so badass!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAFQdFQdN1s&t=0m46s
http://www.spike.com/full-episodes/scsc5s/deadliest-warrior-pirate-vs-knight-season-1-ep-104