Considering that the crowd on the BGS forums has little to no sense of humour and includes some of the most inept people at recognising sarcasm I've ever encountered on the internet, people should really stop making joke topics (they're going to waste).
See, there is this whole problem with text. If you do not use a visual way to display your sarcasm, whether that's
italics, smileys
, or certain phrases, there is
no way to "recognize" sarcasm. Since text lacks, you know, the tone of sarcasm.
Combined with the fact that some people on this forum actually do believe and have stated this idea before I don't really think it is that far out to assume he was not using sarcasm. (whether he is or not)