This. I want to play a game, not a reality simulator.
Pen&Paper RPG'ers complained that Graphical RPG's took away from the imagination and the fantasy with pointless simulation.
MUD'ers said the same about MMO'ers
Each generation, we gain advancements in gameplay, story depth, replayability, graphics and sound. These things are improvements we all grasp. Skyrim looks more like real life than Daggerfall did and when you get used to daggerfall graphics and immediately switch to Skyrim, it appears as though you're in real life.
People who complain won't when that detail becomes commonplace to the lowest common denominators (consoles) in about 20 years. They just state that it isn't artistic when it's still art, just at a much more realistic detail to how it was visualized in the artists head.
http://www.tesnexus.com/imageshare/images/41808-1296413411.jpg http://www.tesnexus.com/imageshare/images/41808-1296411867.jpg.
http://img217.imageshack.us/img217/3811/birdvvardenfell.jpg
I plan to see this level of difference in Skyrim vanilla to Skyrim Modified.