» Fri May 27, 2011 8:11 am
I think we have two different issues, and we need to disentangle them:
1) People talking about the war.
The issue here is that 200 years after the war, people are in the 8th or so generation, and so they would very likely have long forgotten about the war, and post-apocolyptia would have become the new "ordinary". Your parents grew up in the wastes with irradiated water and two-headed cows, your parents' parents, your parents' parents' parents... Especially when you add in the lack of formal schooling on history, and more, the lack of learning materials for those specific individuals desirous of learning history, and the pre-war world would become something of legend. On the other hand, given the tremendous difference between pre-war and post-war, and the catastrophic and enormous chasm between them, it's possible that the memory would endure by virtue of the shear magnitude of its significance.
2) The physical state after the war
The point here is NOT that people are talking about the war; the issue here is that 200 years later, there is still food in the Super Duper Mart, there are still bullets from before the war, etc. How could it be that so much pre-war material has endured? In Fallout, it was plausible, and in Fallout 2, manufacturing had begun again, and people were again producing guns and bullets and such. Just look at NCR: they had standardized police uniforms and street names! Now, NCR was not the norm, but it shows how much recovery had taken place in certain areas. Fallout 2 also had intercity politics and the like, so whereas Fallout gives us the feeling of the great-unknown and the world reeling from catastrophe, Fallout 2 shows us the beginnings of normalization of life. In Fallout 3, NCR was going to have an armed force capable of going toe-to-toe with the BoS (albeit due to greater numbers, but that still means they had capability to arm their soldiers with plenty of 5.56 mm assault rifles and combat armor).
Given all this, it is extremely perplexing how stunted things are in Fallout 3; given that Fallout 3 is after Fallout 2, we'd expect even greater development, perhaps even with re-urbanization of DC and renewal of sewage systems and the like. Instead, we find things in the same state they were in Fallout 1! The explanation would seem to be that whereas in Fallout 1, the Master emerged a few decades after the war, and spent several more decades experimenting with Super Mutants, and thus civilization was not affected by the Super Mutants for some time. And even once they began, it was very slow and gradual, such as taking Necropolis and scouting out stealthily for non-irradiated humans; the Super Mutants did not have any real existence to the towns. Thanks to the Vault Dweller, the Super Mutant threat was nipped in the bud before it really materialized; had the Vault Dweller come a few years later, the Fallout world would have been devastated by the Super Mutants, and Fallout 2 would never have happened. In fact, the Hub was affected by deathclaws far more than by Super Mutants. On the other hand, in Fallout 3, the Super Mutants plagued any attempts at civilization from the very beginning, and only extremely slowly (and especially with the BoS) was mankind able to overcome this opposition, which, unlike Fallout 1 in CA, plagued MD-DC-VA from the very beginning of post-war history. So in some sense, the BoS coming to the East Coast is when MD-DC-VA finally got to the same stage that CA was in Fallout 1, and we can suppose that (hypothetically), in Fallout 4, in another seventy years after Fallout 3, MD-DC-VA will be in the same state that CA was in Fallout 2.
**Edit: Note that in Fallout 1, the BoS played almost no role at all in defeating the Super Mutants; one individual was able to infiltrate two facilities and destroy the key targets within and shut down the entire Super Mutant army before it had a chance to form. However, in Fallout 3, the BoS made a full-scale military assault on the Super Mutants and was merely able to contain them and prevent their further expansion. So in Fallout 3, we see that the Super Mutants had a far far greater foothold in MD-DC-VA than they had in CA in Fallout 1, and this probably explains why the MD-DC-VA area is so far behind where CA is.