Lore, game play, ES history>Any opinion of the ill informed.
Ill informed on TES lore? meh, I'll give you that. My experience with this subject isn't based in games. Taking a realistic approach was probably a bad one.
But still, I don't care about lore (a point I've made consistently), I'd rather see a semi-realistic h2h system anyday over what the lore provides - and it doesn't look like the lore will be having any real influence over this subject in-game any time soon.