... Maybe they shot you in the eyes?
I really don't have any idea, but I never had much issue with the enclave's PA.
Enemies usually just did 0 to 7 in damage, critical hits going as far as maybe 13.
So I dunno, maybe they just got lucky.
Go fight Metzgers Slavers Guild and see what the damage inflicted upon you is.
Lol a vault 15 guard had a 164 crit on me no lie , I was freaking out.
I ended up having to run away with 4hp left.
Ohh where can I find tandi so I can get the ncr to take over vault 15?