1.) look at the table tops, one is darker than the other.
2.) he's being lighted from behind, look at his shadow around his hands.
3.) Beth probably changed the lighting in some unnatural way to put emphasis on the main lady gal.
1. The other one has a candle on the right side, the change in darkness on the counter if applied to his skin is makes him still really dark.
2. Absolutely incorrect. Look at his face and his shirt. Both are lighter on his left side (our right). If you look at the shadows on the stool in front of the bar the shading follows practically the same angle. It just slopes down more because the object is farther down than his chest. The shadow you see from his hands is from the bar patron. You can actually see the shadow of his head on the bartender's shirt on his right side (our left). Look for the small circle that is slightly darker than the rest.
3. There is clearly another light source to the woman's left in front of her. You can see the reflection of it in the metal rings on the barrel.
Like 2 weeks ago I told you guys it was a Redguard. No one believed me. In your face gamesas Forums! (lol)