» Fri Aug 26, 2011 12:49 pm
It's too early to pass judgement. OP, your fears are not really based on leveling alone, but what comes with leveling, like scaled enemies and loot and whatnot. Until we see how the leveling system has been changed in relation to scaling, there's no way to tell if this is a good thing or a bad thing mechanics-wise (I'm not going into the immersion argument at all). For all we know, the actual scaling might not even happen until you've spent either a point on perks or a point on your health/magicka/stamina bars or both. For all we know, your level number might not even go up UNTIL those points are spent. In other words, it's possible that leveling skills only contributes to how many points you get for perks and the three bars, and that those are what affect what level you actually are. If this was the case, you could still be level 1 and have 100 in every skill, but have a mass amount of perk points and stat points unspent.
Of course that's just speculation. The point is, we don't know how the effects of such a system will play out. It's too early to go bashing it with only the current information we have on it.