rockstar does make excellent games but there isn't a comparison , for one thing grand theft auto is a driving game, and red dead redemption is a good game but its kinda like grand theft auto except on a horse, so yeah rockstar games are great but trying to compare rockstar games to bethesda games is dumb. totally different genre's...rockstar games are story driven and the same thing is gonna happen each time, there's no factions, no exploring, no character development, no focus on combat or stealth at all, they have no rpg elements..so when you want exploration, combat, stealth, rpg elements...rockstar games aren't gonna give you that, and for that matter new vegas isn't gonna give you that either...now comparing new vegas and read dead redemption is probably a better comparison, but comparing bethesda games to rockstars is like comparing apples and oranges.
Grand Theft Auto is not a driving a driving game, it is a sandbox game(open world), Fallout 3 and TES are also sandbox games(open world), they can be compared because they are both sandbox games(open world). It's not dumb to compare two similar concepts, it can actually be quite productive. Bethesda could certainly learn somethings from Rockstar. I don't mean game mechanics, but they can learn to put more focus on what makes RPG's interesting instead of just making them big and pretty. This is clearly possible since Rockstar focuses not only on making an incredibly vibrant world(I have always said that Liberty City, Vice City and San Andreas feel like characters in the games), but also manage to make a compelling story, with great dialogue and fascinating characters. Rockstar is far superior to Bethesda in one thing in particular: making you care.
my opinion lines up with the gaming community....what 10 people on a game forum think is inconsequential to bethesdas success as game developers, bethesda has already been recognized for what they do so well, and what they do well, will be continued in FO4 just like it was in oblivion, FO3 and skyrim....the award winning formula stays the same.
There's a special phrase for this, it goes something like cookie cutter games. You're saying that doing the exact thing over and over again is going to satisfy the gaming community? Do not demean them like that.
Don't get me wrong, I love Bethesda and they do an excellent job in making their games fun and pretty, but like anyone they need to be criticized for when they make a lackluster effort in an area.