Assassin's Creed 2. Never played the first one, but the general consensus I got from it was that it had some interesting ideas alongside some gaping flaws. When this came out it was met with universal praise, so I decided it was worth checking out. Some 30 hours later, I have no [censored] clue what's so great about this. It has by far one of the
worst combat systems I have ever played, each of its missions are stupidly repetitive, and the exploration aspect is trashed by the very fact that there's absolutely nothing worth finding in the otherwise gorgeous-looking environments. It's a good thing I never played AC1, because if I didn't like AC2, I most definitely would have
hated part 1.
Xenogears. I played the hell out of the demo that came with Parasite Eve, and it seemed like an interesting game. And, for the most part, it was, though it could be annoyingly wordy and cutscene heavy. And then you reach the second disc, and everything falls apart. The narrative goes out the window, with everything being dumped on through exposition and a few loosely-connected and poorly explained boss fights and dungeons that you have to slog through.
Devil May Cry 2 and 4. The former was a bastardization of the first game in the series made by an idiot who nothing of what made the first one so cool. And the latter was another lazy, by-the-numbers production that Capcom is infamous for.
Also New Vegas, Fallout 3 just seemed like a more cohesive, believeable setting, to hell with canon.
What was so cohesive and believable about Fallout 3's setting? None of the settlements produced anything, no one was growing their own food, seemed the population sustained itself for 200 years off scavenged goods and had made no advancements in that time, the nearest slave buyers were hundreds of miles away, Super Mutants were dumb as bricks and yet were organized enough to nearly overrun the Capital Wasteland (and their whole presence was barely given a cursory glance), and the whole "water purification" plot made no sense even under Fallout's trademark use of bad science. And Little Lamplight.
Everything about Lamplight was nonsense!