My top ten pick? Well, going by mechanics, modability, vanilla's strength, and a lot of other things... Here's mine (currently).
1. Rock Band 3
- Honestly, RB3 isn't my favorite game to play but it is the only game that I love to play which is basically just overall perfect for what it is. Really, the only way someone can actually complain about this game is that it's a music game, and they don't like that genre. That's the only complain anyone can have. (The only other possible complaint was of a bad glitch which could cause the game to crash but Harmonix fixed that already).
2. Halo 1-3
- I'm just bundling the three together honestly because by themselves, they wouldn't be on the list. But altogether, they make the best video game trilogy I've ever played while still having a great gameplay and highly fun multiplayer. I mean, Gears of War and Mass Effect also were great trilogies but Halo was my favorite and they deserve to stay together. (Honestly, same thing with Gears of War and Mass Effect).
3. Morrowind
- Despite the annoyances in the vanilla-based game, Morrowind is the most memorable and fun RPG game I have ever played thus far in my life. With mods, it is by far the BEST RPG game ever (mind you, with mods though. So it doesn't count too much bonus points for it).
4. Fallout: New Vegas
- Very great game as well. Great factions, a good story, great things to do, and so on. There's some issues here and there but overall it's a great game. Also, bonus points for having a good modding community as well.
5. Skyrim
- May have a poor main story but the game overall is still amazingly fun and still has plenty of other strengths. It also did some new great things with magic, which I did honestly enjoyed because it made magic more interesting and good to use. Plus Hearthfire is best house DLC ever. I hope Bethesda keeps the "Hearthfire" idea.
6. Minecraft
- Basically, it does what it should do (though over time, I feel it has gained unnecessary updates) but it's still fun. I personally hadn't updated my PC version of the game for a long time due to the mods I love are not longer being updated, and they outweigh the official updates for myself. So bonus points for the modding community but subtract points for poor updates.
7. Fallout 3
- Overall, great game. Story is a little meh in it and some overall issues throughout the game. However, this was Bethesda's first attempt at Fallout so I'm fine with that. They still manage to do amazing job though with the wasteland.
8. Team Fortress 2
- Honestly, this game could easily be higher but it still lacks some key elements while also having it's own annoyance. However, overall... Definably the best FPS experience I have ever had and has an amazing modding community, hands down.
9. Spyro
- Honestly, nostalgia reasons... I grew up playing Spyro. His first adventure was my first game (back when I was like barely 3). So ye'h... Nostalgia. The game itself is still great for kids though and honestly, if I ever have kids. I'm going to let them try the little purple guy.
10. RuneScape
- As much I would love to dislike Jagex and some of the changes they have done... They still manage to do enough right with this game to make me do check-ups on it and continue working on the game's world. Honestly, this game what really got me into RPGs, lore, and all that fun stuff (rather than just playing the game randomly and doing stupid stuff). So ye'h... I believe it deserves a mention.